Gift Rabbit is supported by our readers. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

57 Cute First Valentine’s Gifts For Boyfriends: 2024 Guide

Let these memorable first Valentine's gifts for boyfriends set the stage for a wonderful relationship.

Your first Valentine’s Day as a couple can bring a lot of unexpected stress. You want to find the top first Valentine’s gifts for boyfriends he’ll treasure. But, it may not be so easy to know what will keep Cupid on your side and your boyfriend’s smile on his face.

Our delightful list has everything you’ll need, from cool DIY kits to classic keepsakes guys value. Find loads of unique first Valentine’s Day gift ideas here for the first of many holidays you spend together.

57 Best First Valentine’s Day Gift Ideas for Boyfriends

Celebrate love in all the right ways with the perfect first Valentine’s gifts for boyfriends that will win their hearts.

Sort by
🕵️ No results found. Clear the Filters?

Personalized Photo Keychain

  • The Perfect Photos

  • $$$$$
  • Personalized, Accessories, Modern

Your first Valentine’s Day together is the perfect time to give your boyfriend this personalized keychain, which isn’t as simple as it seems. It looks like a pre-digital roll of film which displays your favorite photos. Up to 10 photos can be used whenever he needs a reminder of how lucky he is. You can also use photos from a treasured film, show, or video.

User Experience

This keychain is a delightful keepsake, featuring easily scannable Spotify codes and room for cherished photos. Despite the pictures not being top-notch quality due to their small size, they still look acceptable and add a personal touch. It's worth noting the keychain isn't incredibly sturdy, as it's made from paper rolled into thin plastic, but it holds up fine on a day to day basis. Additionally, the wooden camera box it comes with is a nice touch, adding to the overall charm of this unique gift.

First Valentine’s Day Photo Frame

  • Make It Official

  • $$$$$
  • Keepsake, Romantic, Traditional

Valentine’s Day is about capturing the love you want to celebrate. If it’s the first between you and your boyfriend, this photo frame is the best way to show it off. This wood frame celebrates your new relationship, whether in middle school, high school, or college. It displays your favorite photo with the words “Our First Valentine’s Day.”

Personal Perspective

Great purchase, this picture frame is truly a standout! I was taken aback by the intricate detailing and the quality of the engraving - it looked just like the picture. It has a special place in our home, holding a cherished photo and gaining several compliments. Plus, the eco-friendly aspect of using recycled wood products adds an extra layer of satisfaction.

Couple’s Memory Journal

  • A Series Of Firsts

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Modern

Get him started keeping the memories of your new relationship with this couple’s journal he can keep for Valentine’s Day. It’s filled with many fill-in-the-blanks he can easily complete as time together goes by. The memory journal becomes an early reminder of your new boyfriend’s first Valentine’s gifts from you.

Engraved Wooden Watch

  • A Special Message

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Keepsake

The handsome style of this engraved wooden watch can leave a lasting impression on your boyfriend. It has a quality Quartz movement providing time-telling capabilities that won’t quit. The back of the watch is engraved with a surprise message “To my Boyfriend” he’ll love, “I will forever and always be yours and only yours.”

First-Hand Impression

My experience with this watch was positive from the get-go. It arrived, not only with the watch itself, but also packaged with a box, tools, and bracelets - a pleasant surprise! The watch has an amazing quality to it, exceeding my expectations, and it made a perfect anniversary gift for my husband who found it quite impressive. He now treasures this unique piece so much that he keeps it in a case, admiring it regularly. I also found it to be a great value for a stylish and classy watch. The personalized touch on the back was an appreciated bonus, making it an even more special gift.

Multi-Tool Pen Gadget

  • Small, Yet Smart

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Practical

Your boyfriend is the guy you love most, but he’s still a guy that might enjoy this multi-tool pen for your first Valentine’s Day. It’s more than a pen; it’s special in many ways. After writing with the ballpoint pen, he can break glass, open bottles, hold emergency aspirin, or balance his phone. He could feel like James Bond after a few hours with this original accessory.

User Experience

If you're considering this pen as a gift, it's got a lot to offer, but it falls short in a few key areas. My husband found it easy to use and enjoyed exploring its many features, but was frustrated by the lack of storage for its various parts. The pen itself is quite light and lacks a feeling of sturdiness, and the pills compartment is just another cap area, causing the pills to fall out when the pen is unscrewed. Despite these minor setbacks, it brings a smile to my hubby's face each time he uses it.

Personalized Bracelet

  • His Alone

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Keepsake, Modern, Romantic

Traditional looks slightly different with this personalized bracelet for men. Your boyfriend can enjoy the stainless steel design, but it’s the photo of you both that he’ll love most. The bracelet is also customized with both your name and whatever creative text you come up with. Whether he’s at work, outdoors, or at home with you, it’s a timeless piece that’ll stay with him forever.

Personal Perspective

Great attention to detail has been invested in this bracelet, from its comfortable fit to its appreciable weight. Despite the initial disappointment with the clarity of the picture, a corrected version showcased an absolutely beautiful image, pleasing to both myself and the intended recipients. The text is easy to read, and the material is of high quality; neither myself nor my wife had any adverse skin reactions. On the downside, some buyers might find the image too light or difficult to see.

Personalized Whiskey Decanter Set

  • A Personalized Bar

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Cool, Personalized

Valentine’s Day is ready to wow your boyfriend with this personalized whiskey decanter set. The beautiful wooden box contains a whiskey decanter with a set of four matching glasses. They are also monogrammed with his first initial to give them a distinguished feel. It makes a fine addition to his entertaining space, where he’s bound to toast his next drink to you.

Community Feedback

For a unique gift, this engraved decanter set really hit the mark. When I first received the set, I was pleasantly surprised by the wonderful burnt wood smell from the box, indicating the high-quality engraving. However, I did find that the coasters, while protected by foam, had come loose in their compartments. Despite this, the glasses and the decanter remained unscathed, displaying beautiful and regal customizations. The wooden box, while lightweight and somewhat flimsy, added an extra layer of elegance to the gift. Despite the slightly higher cost, this decanter set was well-received by all who I gifted it to, making it a successful and memorable present.

Nightstand Organizer

  • Keep Him Organized

  • $$$$$
  • Practical, Accessories, Modern

If you can’t decide what to get him for your first Valentine’s Day, this nightstand organizer is a great start. It’s a practical way for him to keep his personal possessions organized. The wood station holds a cell phone, watch, keys, glasses, and other small items. It’ll help keep his things in one place whenever he looks for something.

First-Hand Impression

Bought this docking station as a gift and was impressed by the quality of the wood and the modern, stylish design. It has proved to be a functional addition to our home decor, providing a designated space for essentials like phone, watch, wallet, and keys, which has helped prevent misplacement. The assembly was straightforward, although some pieces required a bit of extra force to align correctly. Despite this minor hiccup, the final result looked just as great as advertised. While it's lovely on a nightstand, it's lightweight enough to be portable for travel, making it a versatile piece.

Cryptex Puzzle Box

  • The Game Of Love

  • $$$$$
  • Keepsake, Cool, Modern

This cryptex puzzle box is one of the coolest ways to surprise your boyfriend for Valentine’s Day. It’s inspired by the Da Vinci Code films and will challenge him to open it using a specific letter arrangement. You can customize it to any code, but it comes pre-loaded with the romantic words “I love you.”

User Experience

My experience with this puzzle box has been nothing short of delightful. This product has a solid, weighty feel to it, indicating its high-quality construction. I particularly appreciated its ability to be easily customized with a unique password of my choosing. While the provided set screws may not withstand too much force, the manufacturers thoughtfully included a spare set. This puzzle box not only served as an engaging gift, but also as a unique, intriguing addition to my collection of keepsakes.

RFID Blocking Wallet

  • Stay Safe

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Cool

A wallet may not seem super romantic for Valentine’s Day, but if it’s your first together, this practical gift may make the most sense. Not only is it solidly constructed to house his cards and cash. The wallet has RFID-blocking abilities to prevent any digital hackers from getting too close. He’ll value the way it protects him from nefarious forces and appreciate it coming from you.

Personal Perspective

This slim wallet has quickly become a favorite of mine. Its RFID blocking feature offers peace of mind, securing my cards from potential theft, while its compact size fits comfortably into my back pocket. The thumb-slide pocket is handy, although I'm still deciding on its best use, and although the clip for bills can make the wallet bulgy if used, keeping my cash in my front pocket maintains the wallet's slim profile. One word of caution: this wallet offers little room for extra items, so for the single guys out there, you might need to find an alternative place for certain, ahem, protection.
Gifts You Might Also Like
valentine's gifts for dadGuide to the Best Valentine's Gifts for Dads: Unique, Personalized, and More
long distance relationship giftsGifts That Make Your Long Distance Lover Feel Important
Diy Gift Ideas For BoyfriendThoughtful DIY Gift Ideas for Every Kind of Boyfriend

Create Your Own Reel Viewer

  • Nostalgia Maker

  • $$$$$
  • Keepsake, Cool, Personalized, Modern

Even if your boyfriend wasn’t a kid when reel viewers were in vogue, he could have one for Valentine’s Day. This reel viewer looks like the original ones; only it’s customized with a set of photos you choose. It’s a quirky yet cute keepsake, whether you’re nearby or in a long-distance relationship.

DIY Hot Sauce Set

  • He’s On Fire

  • $$$$$
  • Set, DIY, Cool

Give your boyfriend this DIY hot sauce set and watch him approve of its fiery gourmet flavors. The set has everything he needs to prepare his own collection of hot sauces. From a set of containers to spice and pepper flavoring packets, he’ll have it all at hand. Traditional flavors like cumin and cayenne are joined by unique ones, from Jamaican allspice to Guajillo peppers.

First-Hand Impression

I'm thrilled by the creative potential offered by this hot sauce kit. The variety of ingredients allowed me to experiment with different flavors, although I did have to add some extra heat to suit my taste. While I found the sauce-making process simple, I was surprised the kit didn't include instructions on how to sanitize the jars. Despite being slightly sweet, my homemade hot sauces have been a hit at family dinners.

Graphic Sweatshirt Hoodie

  • Wear Every Day

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Modern

This graphic sweatshirt hoodie may not be the most romantic on Valentine’s Day, but it still proves you care. The hoodie’s soft cotton and comfy fit will quickly make it one of his favorite casual pieces in his wardrobe. He doesn’t need to be a teenager to love the universal style it provides him, no matter what he’s up to.

User Experience

I found this hoodie to be extremely warm, comfortable, and durable, making it ideal for chillier weather and it held up wonderfully even after multiple washes. Despite the fact that it runs a bit large, its high-quality construction and the rarity of finding such well-made sweatshirts for bigger individuals like myself, made it a worthwhile purchase.

Love Note Messenger

  • Special Delivery

  • $$$$$
  • Romantic, Modern, Keepsake, Cool

Few other first Valentine’s Day gifts for him are as unique as this love note messenger device. It may look like a small box with a digital heart design, but there’s much more. Once opened, he can watch photos and videos you can send him anytime. Every time you add a new one, the messenger’s heart turns around to let him know love’s come to town.

Personal Perspective

This little gadget has truly added a sprinkle of magic to my long-distance relationship. Seeing the heart spinning when a new message arrives brings a unique flavor of anticipation that conventional texting can't replicate. Sharing photos is lots of fun, transforming the usual communication into something more personal and special. However, it's worth noting, the device's connectivity is limited to private Wi-Fi networks, not public ones requiring acceptance of terms and conditions.

Personalized LED Song Light

  • Play His Song

  • $$$$$
  • Modern, Romantic, Keepsake, Cool

This personalized LED song light can serve as a romantic reminder of a song that means something to you and your boyfriend. The acrylic night light shows off your chosen photo to replicate a Spotify album cover, the song’s QR code, your names, and a special date. It’ll allow him to see and hear his song out loud when it once only lived in his head.

Community Feedback

Definitely, this gift impressed me with its crystal-clear image and vibrant illumination, creating a captivating visual impact. However, I did notice a slight wobble when inserting the design into the wooden base, and the auto-off after an hour was a bit inconvenient, needing manual reactivation. Despite these minor issues, this gift's high quality and personalization aspect made it feel incredibly special, although it did require some effort to peel off the protective layer.

Valentine’s Day Tumbler

  • Love Wins

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Romantic

Easy, cheap gifts like this Valentine’s Day tumbler may be just the thing to mark your first one together. It’s a useful accessory that he can use to keep his beverages hot or cold while on the move. The stainless steel tumbler has a design that reads, “Love you most. The end. I win.”

Leather Journal

  • In His Own Words

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Personalized

This customized leather journal’s sophisticated look and feel can make your boyfriend love Valentine’s Day. The leather journal is personalized with an engraving of up to five lines of your choosing. Inside is where he can record all his thoughts and dreams or pen a romantic love poem in your honor.

User Experience

For a gift that leaves a lasting impression, this journal hits the mark. The quality of the material is impressive, and the carefully crafted wording - free from errors - adds to its charm. I was moved by how my husband treasured this journal, a testament to its sentimental value. The sturdy pages and the pleasant leather scent further enhance the overall experience of using this special journal.

Bluetooth Beanie Hat

  • Music Man

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Modern, Cool, Practical

The guy you call your boyfriend will get a kick out of this Bluetooth beanie hat. It’ll keep his head warm whenever he needs it, but has much more to offer. The hat is equipped with headphones he can use for music or talking on the phone. It pairs easily with smart devices, so he doesn’t have to worry about getting his headphones tangled anymore.

Personal Perspective

Excellent is the word to describe this hat which I bought for my son. Throughout winter, he utilized it for his runs and driveway plowing tasks, although he mentioned it became itchy when he got hot, and the speaker could be of better quality. The hat is simple to use, fits well, and its soft material makes it ideal for music listening during walks or hikes. Despite the minor issues, my son and others to whom I've gifted this hat have expressed their love for it, especially applauding the loud and clear sound.

Best Boyfriend Mug

  • Nerdy Love

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Cool

Why beat around the bush for your first Valentine’s Day? Give your boyfriend this fun, inexpensive mug he can use every day. It’s made for guys who love Star Wars and all things Sci-fi. The mug reads “Best boyfriend in the galaxy,” in the recognizable design. Every sip he takes may feel like an adventure you provided to him.

Community Feedback

When I gifted this Star Wars mug to my boyfriend, his reaction was priceless. He enjoys using it for his daily coffee and chai tea, and it perfectly complements his Star Wars-themed workspace. Its sturdy design withstands regular dishwasher cycles, maintaining its cool aesthetics. This mug has also sparked quite a few entertaining conversations among our friends, making it more than just a beverage holder.

Cocktail Smoker Kit

  • A Cloud Of Smoke

  • $$$$$
  • DIY, Set, Cool, Modern

This cocktail smoker kit may be the most direct way to your boyfriend’s heart. It’s got the power of DIY behind it to provide tons of fun. The set has a smoker, a stirrer, and a torch to get him started. The wood chips include notes like apple, pecan, and oak to help him make unforgettable cocktails.

First-Hand Impression

This smoking kit left a bit of a mixed impression on me. Initially, the lack of instructions gave me a hard time, but after some online research, my husband and I figured out how to effectively use it. The variety of woods provided subtly different flavors to our cocktails, with the Old Fashioned being our favorite. However, the product was missing the smoking lid filter, which was quite disappointing.
Discover More Unique Gift Suggestions
Valentines Day Facts And StatisticsValentine's Day — Unraveling the Facts and Statistics Behind the Love
Cheap Valentines Day Gift IdeasSave Money and Impress Your Love: Affordable Valentine’s Day Gifts
Funny Valentines Day Gift IdeasThoughtful Yet Hilarious: Valentine’s Day Gift Ideas

Custom Message Shortbread Cookies

  • Love Notes

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Romantic, Cool

It’s not just women who love to get delicious Valentine’s Day treats. Your boyfriend can dig into this set of two dozen custom shortbread cookies. He may be surprised once he reads the personalized message you choose baked in the cookies. They’ll taste amazing while delivering a message of love to him with every bite.

Valentine’s Day Pen

  • CEO Of Love

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Practical, Keepsake

This may be the most romantic pen there is. It’s a thoughtful Valentine’s Day gift for your boyfriend to cherish with each use. The pen comes in a gift box engraved with the words “I love you most. The end. I win.” He’ll soon realize it’s him that won the best girlfriend around.

Personal Perspective

My experience with this pen has been truly delightful. The weight feels perfect in my hand, allowing for smooth and effortless writing. This pen even comes in a stylish box, making it presentable and extra special. The engraved love saying adds a personal touch that is both clean and beautiful. While I've purchased many pens before, this one stands out for its affordability and overall quality.

Heated Razor Shave Kit

  • A Handsome Face

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Practical, Cool

Spa products sometimes get lost on guys, but your boyfriend will surely appreciate this heated razor shave kit. The unique approach to shaving uses the charging station to heat up the razor for use. He’ll adore the warm shave every time he uses it. The set also comes with two refills and a cleaning cloth to keep things running smoothly.

Community Feedback

In using this heated razor, I found that the warmth added a unique comfort to my shaving routine, despite initially viewing it as a gimmick. The replacement blades seemed to dull quicker than my previous 5-blade systems, and attaching a new blade proved somewhat tricky, requiring a specific angle. Nevertheless, the quality of shave was impressive, with the razor delivering a close, irritation-free cut even on my sensitive skin.

Men’s Outdoor Gifts Set

  • The Great Outdoors

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Cool, Accessories

You could spend your first Valentine’s Day together impressing your boyfriend with this awesome gift box of manly items. It’s got tons of fun accessories for the man who loves a great adventure. Survivalist products like a ferro rod for starting a fire and an outdoor knife will keep him protected. He’ll also love using the coffee grit soap and enjoy the aroma of the candle tin.

First-Hand Impression

I'm thoroughly impressed with this gift set which caters perfectly to the outdoor enthusiast in me. The spring-assisted knife from this kit stands out as the most useful tool; it's well-crafted and handy for my camping trips. This gift's tumbler and fire starter further enhance its allure, offering practicality for the great outdoors. The added bonus of a musky scented candle and unique coffee grit soap create a distinctly masculine appeal, making this set not just functional but also indulgent.

Love Capsule Letters

  • One A Day

  • $$$$$
  • Romantic, Modern, Set, Keepsake

This jar of love capsules is filled with pre-written romantic messages for your boyfriend. It’s a lighthearted option for first Valentine’s Day gift ideas for boyfriends. Each of the 60 capsules’ notes has phrases to touch his heart. Words like “Not going to lie, I wish we could be together” are there for him for the times when you’re not.

Grave Before Shave Beard Set

  • Get Grooming Ready

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Cool

Whether your boyfriend has a beard or is trying to grow one for Valentine’s Day, this shave set will help. It contains a companion duo of beard wash and conditioner to keep his whiskers looking and feeling their best. Argan oil makes sure his skin stays supple no matter how manly a guy he is.

Personal Perspective

I'm impressed with how well this beard wash and conditioner softens my beard and keeps my skin feeling great too. However, while it's not unpleasant, the scent is rather potent, almost like having a cologne on your face, which might not be everyone's cup of tea.

Deep Tissue Massage Gun

  • Total Therapy

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Practical

Love protects your boyfriend from emotional pain, but even a man in love needs help with a sore back. This deep-tissue massage gun may be the useful accessory he’s looking for this Valentine’s Day. It’s handheld, so it’s easy to control the intensity and focus. The device comes with eight attachments to suit whatever hurts him most at the moment.

Community Feedback

In my experience, this massage gun held up impressively for almost a year before it began to falter in terms of battery life. It's not as refined in its vibrations as some high-end brands like Hypervolt or Theragun, but it's been a real boon for my back and has done wonders in providing pain relief for my mother's arthritis and post-surgery discomfort.

Engraved Pocket Knife

  • A Tool For Him

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Keepsake, Cool

This engraved pocket knife may be your boyfriend’s idea of something romantic for your first Valentine’s Day together. The handle and the wooden box are customized with his initial, name, and message of your choice. The keepsake knife may come in handy, but it’ll soon become a treasured memento of how much you care.

First-Hand Impression

Got this knife as a special present for my son's 18th birthday and the quality, from the engraving to the sturdiness, left us both stunned. The beauty of this knife is not just skin-deep; it's a well-functioning piece that would impress any pocket knife collector. Despite concerns about the lightweight box it comes in, the overall aesthetic and performance of this knife make it a memorable and satisfying gift.

Valentine’s Day Flask

  • No Truer Words

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Romantic

This romantic flask is a wonderful token of love to share with him on Valentine’s Day. Its classic matte design can fit into his personal collection no matter his style. The flask holds six ounces of liquor and reads “I Love You” in a script that looks like you wrote it yourself.

User Experience

This bottle, although smaller than expected, is exceptionally well-crafted. My spouse absolutely adores it, and the thoughtful inscription adds a personal touch that we both appreciate. While I initially believed I was purchasing the entire box featured in the promotional video, the single bottle that arrived still managed to impress. Despite some initial confusion, this product has positively enhanced our home.

Illuminated Constellation Cufflinks

  • Stylish Stars

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Personalized, Set

Why get your boyfriend regular cufflinks for Valentine’s Day when you can give him these constellation cufflinks? The handmade set shows off the constellation of his zodiac sign and illuminates in the dark. He can look forward to putting them on for special occasions or anytime he’s going to meet up with you.

More Great Gifts to Consider
Valentines Day Gift Ideas For HerDazzle Your Lady Love: Valentine's Day Gifts for Her
Valentines Day Gift Ideas For FriendsValentine's Day Gifts: Making Your Friends Feel Special
Valentines Day Gift Ideas For MomsFrom Practical to Expensive: Valentine's Day Gifts for Moms

Luxury Spa Gift Set

  • The Power Of Sandalwood

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Modern

This luxurious spa gift set is made for guys who still want to be pampered in honor of Valentine’s Day. The toiletry bag is filled with sandalwood-scented products to keep him looking his best. It includes a body lotion, body scrub, and bath salt for his own spa day. There’s also bath soap, body wash, and a loofah to transform his daily shower into something he’ll remember.

Community Feedback

My experience with this luxury spa gift was primarily positive, especially as it served as a perfect finishing touch to a care package I was assembling. The inclusion of everything necessary, neatly packaged in a nice bag, was appreciated. The natural scent, while strong and potentially off-putting to some, was a hit with my 21-year-old son. However, if you're sensitive to strong or natural scents, you might want to reconsider this gift, as it did make me feel a bit flu-like.

DIY Gin-Making Kit

  • No Prohibition

  • $$$$$
  • DIY, Set, Cool, Accessories

Give your boyfriend his own DIY project to honor your first Valentine’s Day as a couple. This gin-making kit will challenge him to craft his own particular brand of homemade liquor. It’s got everything needed to flavor his brew with notes like cardamom, lemon peel, and anise. The result should be something as unique and unforgettable as he is to you.

First-Hand Impression

Best gin-making kit I've ever encountered, this kit offers a multitude of spices and tools to explore the art of gin creation. I found the tip cards with spice combinations and gin history particularly enlightening. Despite the unexpected instruction about involving children, the process was enjoyable and resulted in unique, flavorful batches. My favorite part was experimenting with the included peppercorns for a spicier blend.

Jerky Snacks Heart Gift

  • A Man’s Heart

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Cool, Romantic

This jerky heart combines the traditional romantic idea of a heart-shaped box with beef jerky snacks. Once he opens it up, he’ll discover a load of delicious jerky treats at his disposal. The set of 13 packets has flavors like sesame teriyaki beef jerky and sriracha honey turkey jerky. He won’t know where to start, but he’ll definitely finish asap.

User Experience

My experience with this jerky heart box was a bit of a mixed bag; while the assorted flavors were a delightful surprise, the missing stick was undeniably disappointing. Despite the minor setback, the root beer flavored jerky was a standout favorite, and the unique presentation made for a fun gifting experience.

Little Moments Of Love Book

  • A Romantic Adventure

  • $$$$$
  • Romantic, Modern, Cool

This trendy Little Moments of Love book is a whimsical way to spend your first Valentine’s Day with your boyfriend. Guys who love comic books will appreciate the artful drawings that celebrate love. The comics are both funny and touching at the same time. It’ll make a welcome addition to his collection because it came from you.

Personal Perspective

My experience with this comic book series has been nothing short of delightful. The content, which details the tender moments between two individuals in love, is both relatable and heartwarming, making me reminisce about my past relationships. I particularly enjoyed the simple yet effective artwork that conveyed a deep appreciation for life's little joys. However, I must note that the book's small font size may pose a challenge for those with vision problems, so you might end up reaching for a magnifying glass.

Ticket Stub Diary

  • Memento Maker

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, DIY

DIY meets romantic dates with your boyfriend when you give him this ticket stub diary. He can use his creative style to keep every memento from your first months as a couple together. The scrapbooking album has plenty of space for ticket stubs, menus, and show programs. He can also keep seashells, napkins, or anything he’s collected to remember the best times you’ve shared.

Community Feedback

My experience with this ticket stub book has been largely positive. The book's large pockets accommodate tickets of varying sizes and the memo space allows for notes and personal ratings, making it a great way to preserve memories. I've found the additional full-sleeved pages at the back useful for storing special mementos, and the wire-bound hard cover gives it durability. However, the elastic band intended to secure tickets seems ineffective and unnecessary, but this doesn't detract from the overall functionality of the book.

Personalized Toblerone Chocolate Bar

  • More Than A Box Of Chocolates

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Personalized, Cool

Your boyfriend may be spoiled once you get him this giant custom Toblerone bar for his first Valentine’s Day. It’s hilariously big and personalized with his name on the outside. The larger bar holds eight Toblerone bars of various varieties. The popular chocolate bars will satisfy his sweet tooth for a long time to come.

First-Hand Impression

Bought this giant Toblerone as a gift, and it truly lived up to expectations with its massive size and delightful taste. Although the delivery took longer than anticipated due to international shipping and customs, I found it best to plan ahead for such delays and to consider weather conditions as the chocolate doesn't come with cold packs. Unfortunately, while the product was advertised as customizable, the personalization aspect fell short; my requested messages were not printed on the box. Nevertheless, the recipients thoroughly enjoyed this treat, making it a substantial and enjoyable gift, especially if you have time and cooler weather on your side.

Custom Dog Tag Necklace

  • Keep Close

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Personalized

This dog tag necklace uses a personal photo for your boyfriend to keep nearby. The stainless steel design is rugged enough for him to wear every day over or under his shirt. It’s personalized with a photo and whatever message you want to give to him. He may not be overseas, but he’ll be able to keep you in mind all the time.

User Experience

"Best described as a symbol of love, this item resonates with good quality and a personal touch, despite the initial hiccup of misspelling my engraving, which is solely my fault. The lightweight chain, though a tad short for my preference, doesn't detract from the overall beauty of the piece - the gold looks surprisingly genuine. It's a well-made item that holds sentimental value - my puppy's memory lives on through it, making this product a quietly impressive offering in its price range."

Customized Photo Socks

  • Give Him Your Heart

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Set, Practical

These customized photo socks may look great with your boyfriend’s face all over them. You could also use a photo of your face to turn your first Valentine’s Day into something humorous. The socks are covered with whichever photo you choose, plus red hearts as an ode to the holiday. Either way, they’re bound to make him smile.

Personal Perspective

These custom-designed socks made a delightful gift! The print quality was top-notch, and the picture placement was done with care. However, I did notice that the socks run small, particularly for those with larger feet (size 9 and above). Although the face did slightly distort when stretched over a larger foot, the overall comfort and softness of the socks were still impressive. Despite a minor discoloration when worn, the hilarious reaction from the recipient made the purchase worthwhile.

Coffee Accessory Gift Set

  • All Things Caffeinated

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Cool

Coffee is the language of love for some, which is why this coffee gift set can make his heart sing. It has a tasty coffee blend and a wooden measuring spoon, plus other cool items that focus on coffee itself. The set has a cute ceramic mug, a tote bag, a pair of novelty socks, and a vanilla latte candle.

Community Feedback

Great gift box, especially for coffee enthusiasts. This gift box offered a high-quality thermos that impressively maintained my coffee's temperature and a pair of soft, humorous socks that added a fun touch. However, the images were a bit misleading, as they featured a coffee mug, but only an insulated tumbler was included, and the box arrived with non-removable stickers, cheapening the overall appearance.

Foodie Dice

  • Dinner Date

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Modern, Set

These foodie dice are the perfect gift for your boyfriend so he can make dinner with you extra special. The set of dice makes cooking dinner a lot more spontaneous. When he rolls the dice, he’ll get options like cooking method, protein, carb, seasonal veggies, herbs, and a bonus ingredient. An unforgettable meal is surely coming your way very soon.

First-Hand Impression

My experience with this foodie dice gift was delightful. The compact size makes it easy to store in a kitchen drawer, and adds an element of surprise during meal prep. Although the lettering on the dice is a bit small, the words are clear and easy to read, making it a fun and engaging way to explore new culinary possibilities. However, be mindful of the size-to-price ratio, as the dice are smaller than expected for the cost.
Check Out These Gift Ideas Next
Valentines Day Gifts For HimAim Your Arrow Right: Thoughtful Valentine's Day Gifts for Him
Valentines Day Gift Ideas For TeachersValentine's Day Gifts for Teachers — From Practical to Personalized
Diy Valentines Gift IdeasValentine’s Day — The DIY Gift Trend That’s Sweeping Hearts

DIY Wood-Carving Kit

  • A Woodsman

  • $$$$$
  • DIY, Set, Cool

This DIY wood-carving kit gets your boyfriend involved in all things crafty this Valentine’s Day. It’s the ideal place for him to start his wood-whittling side hustle. The set has a series of knives and helpful instructions to keep his work focused. He’ll end up with a new hobby and you’ll end up with a wooden keepsake of his own making.

User Experience

As a seasoned craftsman dabbling in wood and leather, I found this 3-knife carving set refreshingly high-quality. The knives, made from tool steel, arrived sharp and maintained their edge impressively, even with my heavy use on tough Douglas fir. Despite my initial skepticism about the included 'green' compound, I found it useful for maintaining blade sharpness, and the sturdy, military-looking canvas roll provided a convenient storage solution.

Love Pillowcase

  • A Stand In

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Traditional

Your boyfriend can keep this love pillowcase close by when he misses you. It fits an 18 by 18-inch square pillow and is a cute way to show him you care. The soft cotton will make him feel welcome, as will the words. The pillow reads, “Never forget that I love you. Hug this pillow until you can hug me.”

Personal Perspective

My experience with this pillow cover has been mostly positive. It fits most of the throw pillows in my house perfectly, although it's a bit snug on the bigger ones. The material is soft and comfy, making it an excellent choice for a cozy cuddle. However, the zipper isn't the sturdiest and broke after some usage, so maybe a metal zipper would be a better choice. Also, take note, it's just the cover, not an actual pillow - I had to find a pillow to put in it.

Beer-Chilling Coasters

  • The Perfect Fit

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Practical, Cool

These beer-chilling coasters take coffee table decor up a notch for his living room. They’re the kind of first Valentine’s gifts for boyfriends that he’ll actually love to have. The set of two stone coasters has options to fit a beer bottle or a beer can. They’ll keep his beer cold, so he can focus on having the best time with you, his Valentine.

100-Dates Scratch-Off Poster

  • Exercise In Spontaneity

  • $$$$$
  • Romantic, Modern, DIY

You can solve a problem for your boyfriend going forward from your first Valentine’s Day. This 100-dates scratch-off poster will give him all the fun ideas he needs to plan your next year together. The date ideas include tons of fresh choices, from recreating your first date to visiting a botanical garden.

First-Hand Impression

This poster is a delightful mix of simple and elaborate date ideas, which keeps things fresh and exciting. However, I found the boxes quite challenging to scratch off, requiring more force than expected. Despite the minor inconvenience and some spelling errors, the poster serves as a fun, interactive guide for couples looking to spice things up.

Hummer Chrome Cologne

  • Scent Of A Man

  • $$$$$
  • Modern, Cool, Accessories

Short of getting your boyfriend a Hummer for his first Valentine’s Day with you, this cologne can be a success. It’s a creatively put-together eau-de-toilette spray with a unique scent profile. From bergamot and cedarwood to notes of gin and tonic and bourbon pepper, it’s got everything he enjoys in life.

User Experience

From my personal experience, this cologne offers a pleasant scent that draws numerous compliments, even in social settings like bars. The fragrance lingers effectively throughout the day, adding to its appeal. However, the sprayer mechanism could use some improvement as it jammed before the cologne ran out in my previous bottle. Despite this, among my collection, this cologne stands out for its superior aroma and long-lasting effect.

Satin Pajama Set

  • Like A Prince

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Practical

The classic satin feel to this satin pajama set can make your boyfriend smile. He’ll love lounging around with you for Valentine’s Day, or anytime he can. The pajamas are lightweight and breathable, but will make sure he feels his coziest when he spends time with you. They’ll speak to his inner gentleman and ensure he has the best night’s sleep.

Personal Perspective

From the moment I slipped into these green silk pajamas, I was impressed by their perfect fit and the softness of the exterior fabric. The accent lines added a touch of style that even earned me some compliments during an unexpected trip to the emergency room. Though the interior didn't share the same softness, it was still comfortable and didn't detract from the overall experience. However, be wary of white cotton sheets as the color tends to bleed, even after a few washes.

Men's Skin Care Set

  • A Brave Face

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Accessories, Practical

The men’s skin care set has everything your boyfriend needs to put his best face forward. It has skincare items for men, from a facial wash and scrub to a moisturizer and eye cream. The ingredients include Vitamin E and Argan oil to keep his face super kissable for every Valentine’s Day to come.

Community Feedback

Best skincare routine I've ever tried, hands down. After two months of consistent use, this skincare product has transformed my complexion, significantly reducing my acne and oiliness. Despite the moisturizer only providing about 8 hours of hydration, these products work wonders for my eczema-prone sensitive skin and have given me a more natural glow. The facial scrub could do with a bit more texture, yet it's still manageable, and the eye cream hasn't shown any noticeable results. One major plus is how each product comes in decently-sized bottles, ensuring they last for more than a month. While this is my first foray into men's skincare products, I've been pleasantly surprised by their quality, and the refreshing feeling they give my face is truly something else.

Portable Fire Pit

  • Fireside Chat

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Practical

Your boyfriend doesn’t have to leave the house to share a warm fire with you for Valentine’s Day. Once you give him this portable fire pit, he can toast s’mores or set the mood for outdoorsy romance. The little fire pit provides a safe way to enjoy a campfire anytime. It literally lights up a dining room table, living room coffee table, or wherever he may be.

First-Hand Impression

From the moment I laid eyes on this fire pit bowl, I was smitten. It's compact and attractive design added a cozy and inviting ambiance to my outdoor gatherings. I found it easy to use and it lit up quickly, offering a warm, clean-burning flame that was perfect for making s'mores and warming hands. Although there was a small chip when it arrived and it cracked after the first use, it still served its purpose well. Despite the initial hiccup, this fire pit bowl was a great addition to my camping gear and a hit with my wife who admired its quality and design.

Ugg Neumel Boots

  • Soft On The Inside

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Set

The rugged luxury your boyfriend will experience when he puts on these Ugg Neumel Boots may surprise you. Their stylish look is only made better once he feels the pure wool that lines the inside. They can provide support, comfort, and warmth for his feet, even if he’s on them all day long.

User Experience

After using these boots for winter walks, I can attest to their warmth and comfort, especially in temperatures as low as the 20's and 30's Fahrenheit. I've also received plenty of compliments on them, despite the fact that they can stain easily from water and are a bit tricky to clean. However, the comfort and style of these boots make up for any minor inconveniences, and they are definitely my go-to footwear in the colder months.

Waterproof Bluetooth Speaker

  • Singing In The Shower

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Cool

Your first Valentine’s Day together may be the best time to get your boyfriend this fun shower speaker. It uses Bluetooth to connect to his smart devices so he can call up his favorite tunes. The speaker is waterproof, so it’s safe to use no matter how much he keeps singing in the shower.

Personal Perspective

Definitely, this shower speaker has made our everyday routines more fun - from my teen daughter's shower concerts to our family pool sessions. The LED lights are a captivating touch, creating a mini disco in our bathroom, while the sound remains crisp and clear, even over the noise of running water. We've found the speaker's battery life to be decent, but it appears to drain faster when the lights are on, so we often keep them off. The waterproof feature is a real bonus, providing peace of mind whenever it accidentally tumbles into the tub or pool. All in all, this shower speaker has proven to be a versatile and enjoyable addition to our home.
Explore Additional Gifting Inspirations
Boyfriend Birthday Gift IdeasDiscover Top Boyfriend Birthday Gifts - Thoughtful, Cool, and Unique
Valentines Day Gift Ideas For KidsThoughtful and Practical Valentine's Day Gifts Your Kids Will Cherish

Charging Table Lamp

  • Light Up And Charge

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Cool

The practical guy you spend your first Valentine’s Day with will appreciate this useful charging table lamp. The classic style looks traditional, but its features offer more. It’s a combination lamp, alarm clock, and charging station. He can charge multiple items using USB and plug extensions at once.

Community Feedback

In my experience, this lamp is smaller than it appears in the picture but still meets my needs. The light emitted is bright and the built-in USB and electric plugs add a level of convenience. I also appreciate the easy assembly and the extra features, such as the clock with a dual alarm function. The only drawback I've found is that the side electric plug-ins are too close to the lamp pole, making it challenging to fit certain chargers.

Personalized Picture Plaque

  • The Art Of Romance

  • $$$$$
  • Keepsake, Romantic, Personalized

You could get your boyfriend a photo of you both for Valentine’s Day, or you could give him this personalized wood plaque instead. Whatever photo you provide will be artfully drawn onto the wood piece, so the image is immortalized. The engraving beside the picture includes the words, “I love you more. The end. I win.”

First-Hand Impression

For me, this product proved to be a delightful surprise, exceeding my initial expectations. I found that the line art looked best with less detailed images, giving a unique, almost whimsical, touch to the piece. However, while I personally felt the representation was not completely accurate, it still managed to capture a fun essence and was well-received by my significant other.

Bluetooth Wireless Earbuds

  • Tech Nerd Love

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Practical, Cool

Sometimes, all your boyfriend needs for Valentine’s Day is a terrific set of Bluetooth wireless earbuds. They can replace his old, outdated pair and show him how awesome a listening experience should sound. The earbuds’ case has a digital display, so he’ll know when they’re ready. Once you make something simple better for him, it shows him what true love is.

User Experience

These pink Bluetooth headphones have proven to be more than just a pretty accessory. Their design is sleek and lightweight, allowing for comfortable, cord-free music sessions that don't weigh down my ears. The sound quality is top-notch, with crisp mid-ranges, punchy bass, and detailed highs, making my dive into the world of 8D music thoroughly enjoyable. While they may not have the advanced features of pricier brands, their impressive battery life, easy Bluetooth pairing, and convenient charging case make them a worthy contender in the realm of affordable audio gear.

Outdoor Beer Table

  • Table For Two

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Cool, Modern

Just because Valentine’s Day is all about romance doesn’t mean you can’t give your boyfriend what he really wants. This inventive portable beer table turns any outdoor space into a good time. Once it’s placed into the ground, the small table becomes a secure place for drinking. It’s got places for two beer bottles, a bottle opener, and a spot for snacks you can both share.

BBQ Grill Set

  • Grill Master Man

  • $$$$$
  • Set, Cool, Accessories

This BBQ grill set has everything your boyfriend could want in a gourmet gift box. In addition to a smoke box and an array of wood chips, the set comes with Kansas City and St. Louis barbecue rubs. The spice set has delicious flavors to upgrade his next barbecue, from Southwest, Cajun, and Caribbean, to start.

Community Feedback

I recently gifted this BBQ set to a family member and it was well-received. The sturdy box packed with different rubs and a barbecue sauce made for an appealing presentation. The barbecue sauce was particularly outstanding, adding a delightful flavor to our grilling sessions. However, I did encounter an issue with one of the bottles breaking, so handle these products with extra care.

Engraved Cereal Spoon

  • Spoonful Of Love

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Romantic, Keepsake

The first Valentine’s Day you share with your boyfriend is a good time to start small with gifts. This engraved cereal spoon is an adorable way to show him how much you love him. It could be used like other spoons, but once he discovers it in the utensil drawer, the spoon stands out. It’ll touch his heart with the engraved message “I cerealsly love you!”

First-Hand Impression

I received this spoon as a gift and found it to be quite charming with its long, slender design and humorous inscription. Though its elongated handle is perfect for reaching the bottom of my favorite tall mugs, the spoon's size isn't quite adequate for cereal consumption as it's smaller than a conventional teaspoon. Nonetheless, I utilize it regularly for my tea indulgences and appreciate the thoughtfulness behind the gift.

Romantic Candle

  • Ode to Online Love

  • $$$$$
  • Accessories, Modern, Romantic

This romantic candle is all the mood your boyfriend needs to mark his first Valentine’s Day with you. The black candle features the unique scent of Black Cedar Juniper. Every time it burns, he’ll be greeted with the 21st-century message, “You’re the best thing I’ve ever found on the internet.” The small accessory celebrates the art of online dating when it’s totally successful.

User Experience

I'm pretty thrilled with this candle, which I picked up as a humorous nod to my own online dating success story. The soy wax composition was a plus, and it burned evenly for well over 30 hours, ensuring I got the most out of my purchase. The scent was pleasant, but not overpowering, adding a cozy touch to my home. Despite being a bit smaller than I expected, its uniqueness and charm made it a hit - both with me and my husband.

First Valentine’s Day Gifts for Him FAQs

Do Guys Expect Gifts on Valentine’s Day?

While Valentine’s Day is traditionally seen as a time to shower a woman with gifts, it’s also a great day to let guys know they’re special. It may be a more practical gift they need or something unique they’ve been craving. Valentine’s Day is a thoughtful occasion to bring something new and unexpected into their lives.

What Can I Get My Boyfriend Instead of Flowers?

You can treat your boyfriend to many cool items instead of the flowers traditionally given on Valentine’s Day. Anything music-related is usually welcomed with open arms. Wine, beer, liquor, or any addition to his barware collection could be a hit. Something meaningful that speaks to his favorite hobbies will speak to who he is and why you love him most.

How Do I Make Him Feel Special on Valentine’s Day?

There are many things you can do to make your boyfriend feel special this Valentine’s Day. Setting up the perfect date is one, from the food and drink to a special event he’s been wanting to see. Men appreciate self-care and spa treatments as much as women, which may mean a spa day or gift basket. Any activity he gets to enjoy with you can be his favorite one of all.

How We Choose First Valentines Gifts For Boyfriends

At Gift Rabbit, we understand the challenge of finding the perfect first Valentine’s gift for your boyfriend. We leverage our vast experience and meticulous research to provide you with a diverse assortment of unique gift ideas suitable for various preferences and budgets. Our team thoroughly reviews each product, taking into account factors like price, style, and customer feedback. We consult with experts, survey users, and score products based on set criteria to ensure you get the best recommendations. From romantic keepsakes to personalized items, our guide offers an array of gift ideas that will make your first Valentine’s experience memorable. Trust us to help you compare and choose the best gift for your boyfriend.

Headshot of Maryana Vestic

About the Author

Maryana Vestic

Maryana Vestic is a Brooklyn-based writer, editor, and food photographer with a background in entertainment Business Affairs. She studied film at NYU, Irish Theatre Studies at Trinity College Dublin, and has an MFA in Creative Writing Nonfiction from The New School. She loves cooking, baking, hiking, and horror films, as well as running a local baking business in Brooklyn with her boyfriend.